A spreadsheet wins on discovery: someone already filtered the junk, priced it in USD and attached QC context. Direct search wins on coverage: it reaches new sellers and one-off listings a table will never index. The efficient method is spreadsheet first to learn the price band and the reputable sellers, then direct search for the exact colourway or size you now know you want. Pure spreadsheet buying leaves value on the table; pure scrolling wastes evenings.
Scorecard
Scored 1–5 on the things that change what you pay or what arrives. Scores are editorial, based on how each platform behaves in practice, not on published marketing.
What a good spreadsheet actually does
It compresses a marketplace. Weidian alone has millions of listings with titles in Chinese, prices in CNY and no quality signal. A curated table gives you a shortlist with USD prices, category structure and usually a note about batch quality or a known flaw.
That is worth more than it sounds: the first hour of direct search is spent learning what things cost. A table tells you in five minutes.
Where the table stops helping
New sellers, limited drops, and exact sizes. Tables are updated in batches, so a link can be dead or a price stale. Direct search is also better when you want a specific colourway that never made the curated list.
Treat the table as a map and search as the territory.
The hybrid method I use
Start on a category page, note the price band for the item type, then search the marketplace for the exact model with the seller's own phrasing. Cross-check the seller's rating, the sales count and the review photos. If the price is far below the band, assume a bait listing until proven otherwise.
Then paste the link into the agent, not the marketplace checkout.
Why the link converter matters
Most finds are shared as app links or short links. A converter turns a Weidian item ID, a Taobao ID or a 1688 offer ID into a searchable product URL your agent can ingest, which removes the step where people paste a link that does not resolve.
Side by side
| Dimension | Curated spreadsheet | Direct marketplace search |
|---|---|---|
| Entry point | Category page with USD rows | Search box with Chinese keywords |
| Language | English titles | Chinese titles and slang |
| Price display | USD converted | CNY with platform conversion |
| Curation | Human-filtered | Algorithmic |
| Freshness | Updated in batches | Real time |
| QC notes | Often included | None |
| Dead listings | Possible | Rare |
| Best for | Learning a category | Hunting one exact item |